Buyer Education
Why housing outperforms other investments
On price alone, a home looks like a so-so investment. Home prices have risen about 4.3% a year since 1987, and after taxes, insurance and upkeep, that drops to 1.3%. But according to new Compass research, once you count the rent you don't pay and the power of a mortgage, a homeowner's return on their own money has averaged about 13% a year, ahead of the stock market's 10.9%. Here's the math, step by step.
In this guide
- 01Why price alone undersells housing
- 02The hidden return: rent you don't pay
- 03How a mortgage boosts your return
- 04Forced savings
- 05Why an empty home loses
- 06What it means in New York City
01Lesson
Why does housing look like a weak investment?
Because most comparisons only count price growth. Since 1987, home prices have risen about 4.3% a year on average, slightly below the 4.6% average yield on 10-year government bonds. Subtract roughly 3 percentage points for property taxes, insurance and maintenance, and net price growth falls to 1.3%, below the 2.8% average inflation rate.
If that were the whole story, owning a home would be a poor investment. It isn't the whole story.
Chart 1
Average annual returns since 1987
Housing looks weak on price alone, and strongest once you count rent savings and leverage
Source: Compass research, using S&P Dow Jones Indices (Case-Shiller), BLS, Federal Reserve and Robert Shiller data. Averages since 1987; past returns don't guarantee future results.
02Lesson
What is the hidden return on owning a home?
The rent you don't pay. When you own the home you live in, you're effectively paying rent to yourself. Compass estimates that implied rental return at about 8% of a home's value a year, which turns a 1.3% net price gain into a 9.3% total return.
Key termImplied rent
The rent you would pay to live in your home if you didn't own it. It's a real return, even though it never shows up in your sale price. Owners' equivalent rent makes up 25.9% of the Consumer Price Index.
Rental returns vary by location and over time, but Compass found that the overall return on owning has been fairly stable over time.
03Lesson
How does a mortgage increase my return?
A mortgage lets you control the whole home's return with only part of your own money. Historically, the average 30-year fixed rate has been about 6.2%, below housing's 9.3% total return. That gap works in your favor on every borrowed dollar.
The math
From 9.3% to about 13% on your own cash
- Total return on the whole home9.3% a year
- Average mortgage rateAbout 6.2%
- Average loan-to-value ratio54%
- Return on the homeowner's own moneyAbout 13% a year
Leverage works both ways: it magnifies losses if values fall. These are long-term historical averages, not a forecast.
Chart 2
How a home's return adds up
Each step adds to (or subtracts from) the average annual return
Source: Compass research. Leverage assumes historical averages: a roughly 6.2% mortgage rate and a 54% loan-to-value ratio.
Piece of the return | Average | What it means |
|---|---|---|
Home price growth | 4.3% a year | Average Case-Shiller appreciation since 1987 |
Ownership costs | About −3 points | Property taxes, insurance and maintenance |
Net price growth | 1.3% a year | Below the 2.8% average inflation rate on its own |
Implied rent | About 8% a year | The rent you'd otherwise pay to live there |
Total unlevered return | 9.3% a year | Net price growth plus implied rent |
With a mortgage | About 13% a year | Return on your own money, using a ~6.2% rate and 54% loan-to-value |
Stocks, for comparison | 10.9% a year | Historical stock market return |
Source: Compass research. Averages since 1987.
Wondering whether owning beats renting for you? Contact Darrell Williams for a rent-versus-buy analysis.
04Lesson
Why is a mortgage a form of forced savings?
Because part of every payment builds equity. Principal payments build equity— savings that are harder to spend on impulse than cash in a bank account. Over the years, that adds up alongside the home's own return.
05Lesson
Is it a good idea to buy a home and leave it empty?
Not as an investment. Most of housing's return comes from the rent you don't pay, so a home that sits empty gives up the biggest part of the return. Compass calls it a losing strategy. If you're buying a second home or pied-à-terre, plan to use it, or consider leasing it out when you're away, where the building allows it.
06Lesson
What does this mean for New York City buyers?
The rent side of the math is especially powerful here. In October 2026, the average listed rent was $6,576 a month in Manhattan, $4,667 in Brooklyn and $4,184 in Queens, according to the Compass Rental Market Report. Every one of those dollars is part of what an owner saves.
- Compare total monthly costs Weigh rent against your mortgage, common charges or maintenance, and taxes, not just the purchase price.
- Think in years, not monthsThe longer you stay, the more the rent savings and equity build. Short stays leave less time to cover buying and selling costs.
- Mind the carrying costs NYC taxes, common charges and maintenance vary a lot by building and affect your real return.
- Live in it The return is strongest when the home is your residence, which also keeps it clear of the city's pied-à-terre surcharge.
Questions
Frequently asked questions
Is buying a home a better investment than stocks?
Over time, it can be. According to Compass research, home prices alone have risen about 4.3% a year since 1987, but counting the rent owners don't pay and the effect of a mortgage, a homeowner's return on their own money has averaged about 13%, compared with 10.9% for stocks.
Why does housing look like a weak investment?
Because most comparisons only look at price growth. After taxes, insurance and maintenance, net home price growth averages just 1.3% a year. The biggest part of the return, the rent you no longer pay, doesn't show up in the sale price.
What is implied rent?
Implied rent is the rent you would pay to live in your home if you didn't own it. Compass estimates it at about 8% of a home's value a year on average, and it's the main reason owning has historically outperformed.
How does a mortgage increase my return?
A mortgage lets you control a whole home with a smaller amount of your own money. When the home's total return is higher than your mortgage rate, the difference boosts the return on your down payment. Leverage also increases risk if values fall.
Is a second home or pied-à-terre a good investment?
It depends on how you use it. The strongest returns come from living in the home, because that's where the rent savings come from. Compass notes that buying a home and leaving it empty gives up that return.
Does this apply to New York City?
The study is national, but the logic applies here, especially with high rents. In October 2026, the average listed rent in Manhattan was $6,576 a month, according to Compass, so the rent an owner doesn't pay is a big part of the math.
Should I rent or buy in NYC?
It depends on how long you'll stay, your down payment and the homes you're comparing. Contact Darrell Williams for a rent-versus-buy analysis on the homes you're considering.
This article is general information based on historical averages, not financial or investment advice. Past performance doesn't guarantee future results. Consult a financial advisor about your situation.
Thinking about buying in New York City? Contact Darrell Williams for a private consultation, or view my Compass profile and listings.