Landlord’s Guide to Renting Out a Condo in NYC

November 16, 2026

Renting Out Your Condo

Landlord's Guide to Renting Out a Condo in NYC

Pricing, board approval and who pays the broker now that the FARE Act is law, from a broker who has handled more than 191 rentals across New York City.

Renting out a condo in New York City comes down to three things: pricing it right, getting through your building's approval process and knowing who pays the broker. That last one changed with the FARE Act. Since June 11, 2025, the landlord pays the fee when the landlord hires the broker, and tenants can't be charged for it.

I've handled more than 191 rentals throughout New York City, most of them representing landlords, from Manhattan condos to homes in Brooklyn and Queens. The owners who lease fastest are the ones who plan for all three before the apartment ever hits the market.

Rents are still climbing. The average listed rent reached $6,576 in Manhattan in October 2026, up 4% from a year earlier, according to the Compass Rental Market Report for October 2026. But renters have more choice outside Manhattan, where listings jumped in Brooklyn and Queens.

Here's what every condo owner should know before signing a tenant.

Figure 1

What NYC renters are paying

Average listed rent, studio to three-bedroom, October 2026, with change from a year earlier

Source: Compass Rental Market Report for October 2026.

How should I price my condo for rent?

Price it against what's actually leasing, not what's sitting. Start with recent leases in your building and on nearby blocks, then adjust for floor, light, layout, finishes and amenities like a doorman, gym or outdoor space.

Timing matters too. Demand usually peaks in late spring and summer, and an apartment that lists in winter may need sharper pricing or a small concession to lease quickly.

The costliest mistake I see is overpricing. Every month an apartment sits empty is a month of carrying costs you don't get back, and a price cut later rarely recovers the lost time.

In Brooklyn and Queens, where rental listings rose 18% and 32% from a year earlier, your apartment is competing with more options than it was last year.

Figure 2

More competition outside Manhattan

Change in rental listings from a year earlier, October 2026

Source: Compass Rental Market Report for October 2026. More listings means more choice for renters and more competition for landlords.

How does condo board approval work for a rental?

Most NYC condos require an application and review before a tenant can move in, and every building's rules are different. Here's the typical path.

  1. Read your bylaws and house rulesCheck for minimum lease terms, limits on how often you can lease, sublet rules and any restrictions on furnished or short-term rentals.
  2. Assemble the lease applicationThe building's forms, the signed lease, the tenant's financials and references, and any application, processing or move-in fees.
  3. Board or managing agent reviewMany condos hold a right of first refusal on leases, which is usually waived. Review can take days or weeks depending on the building.
  4. Schedule the move-inBook the elevator, confirm the move-in deposit and certificate of insurance, and make sure the tenant has the building's rules.

Want your condo priced and leased without the board-package headaches? Contact Darrell Williams for a rental pricing analysis.

Who pays the broker fee after the FARE Act?

Whoever hires the broker. If you hire a broker to list and lease your condo, you pay the fee, and it can't be passed on to the tenant, including under another name like a "processing" or "finder's" fee. All fees a tenant does pay must be disclosed in the listing.

Situation

Before June 11, 2025

Under the FARE Act

Landlord hires the broker

Tenant often paid the fee

Landlord pays the broker

Tenant hires their own broker

Tenant paid

Tenant pays, under their own agreement

Fees in the listing

Not always shown up front

All fees tenants pay must be disclosed

Fees under other names

Sometimes charged to tenants

Treated as broker fees and prohibited

For landlords, that means a decision. Some build the cost into their pricing. Others pay it as the price of leasing faster to a well-qualified tenant. Either way, a vacant month often costs more than the fee.

What other rules do NYC landlords need to know?

A few basics apply to every lease. Security deposits are capped at one month's rent under New York State law, and application fees for background and credit checks are capped at $20. Landlords must also follow fair housing laws, which in New York City include protections for tenants who pay with housing vouchers or other lawful sources of income.

From 191+ NYC rentals

Price it right on day one. The first weeks on the market usually bring the most interest. Use them.

Have the board package ready before you list. Knowing your building's forms, fees and timeline keeps a good tenant from moving on to another apartment.

Plan for the fee. Under the FARE Act, decide up front how you'll handle the broker's fee so it doesn't surprise you at signing.

Screen carefully and consistently. Apply the same income and credit standards to every applicant, within fair housing rules.

Frequently asked questions

Who pays the broker fee in NYC after the FARE Act?

Whoever hires the broker pays. Since the FARE Act took effect on June 11, 2025, a landlord who hires a broker to list an apartment pays that broker's fee, and tenants can't be charged for it.

How do I price my condo for rent in NYC?

Start with recent leases in your building and nearby, then adjust for floor, light, layout, finishes and building amenities. In October 2026 the average listed rent was $6,576 in Manhattan, $4,667 in Brooklyn and $4,184 in Queens, according to Compass.

Do I need board approval to rent out my condo?

In most NYC condos, yes. Expect a lease application, a board or managing agent review, fees and sometimes a minimum lease term. Many condos also hold a right of first refusal, which is usually waived. Every building's rules are different, so read your bylaws first.

How long does condo board approval take for a rental?

It varies by building, from a few days to several weeks. A complete application with the tenant's financials and the building's forms is the fastest way through.

How much security deposit can a NYC landlord collect?

Up to one month's rent under New York State law, and application fees for background and credit checks are capped at $20.

Is it worth hiring a broker to rent my condo now that landlords pay?

Many landlords find it is. A broker who knows your building's board process, prices the apartment right and screens tenants can cut vacancy time, which often costs more than the fee.

How do I find a broker to rent out my condo in NYC?

Look for an agent who handles landlord representation and knows condo board approvals. Contact Darrell Williams for a rental pricing analysis.

Thinking about renting out your condo in New York City? Contact Darrell Williams for a private consultation, or view my Compass profile and listings.

Work With Darrell

Darrell Williams works in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx. His expertise includes new development sales/leasing projects, investment sales, and 1st time home buyers. Whether you're purchasing or selling, he'll keep you feeling comfortable and confident from start to end.

Follow Me on Instagram